4 Most Popular Posts on BitcoinTalk

10

I wondered what are the most viewed and discussed threads were on BitcoinTalk. So I went over to the forum and filtered the main “Bitcoin Discussion” section for “Views” and “Replies”. The result are some of the more epic stories in Bitcoin’s evolution.

#4 – The Hal Finney Story

Hal Finney, perhaps the first person besides Satoshi to really throw his weight behind Bitcoin. He’s also one of those few unfortunate people who suffer from ALS, or as it’s more commonly known, Lou Gehrig’s disease. His story of Bitcoin, as you may have guessed, is one of both tragedy and triumph.

Mr. Finney is a cryptographer and while many of his peers rejected Bitcoin when it first started circling around the web, he quickly became excited. Indeed, it is believed that Hal was the first person to participate in a Bitcoin transaction when Satoshi sent him ten Bitcoins to test out the system.

Interestingly, Hal only ran Bitcoin for a few days, using his computer to mine them. He found that the mining process was making his computer run too hot, so he shut off the program and more or less forgot about the coins. He didn’t discard the coins but instead let them sit on his hard drive.

In 2009 Hal, then in mid fifties, was in the best shape of his life. His Bitcoins were gathering dust on his hard drive, but Hal was preparing for a marathon, running twenty plus miles per day. And that’s when he found out about his condition. Lou Gehrig’s disease causes people to essentially lose control of their muscles and fully paralyzes them.

Hal didn’t think much about his Bitcoin until late 2010 when he found out that Bitcoin was worth money he pulled his coins into an offline wallet and decided to hold onto them to give to his heirs one day.

Sadly, Hal is now paralyzed, using a motorized wheel chair and eye controlled devices to get around. He also has to use a voice synthesizer. But where many of us might crack, Hal has remained a positive outlook on life. He’s still holding onto his Bitcoins and he’s still involved in programming and other things.

BitcoinTalk readers were truly inspired by the story and some even think that Hal may be Satoshi himself. Read the full thread.

#3 – The dude who bought 250,000BTC for $3,000 (2nd most viewed)

One of the most popular Bitcoin forum threads is entitled “I’m Kevin, here’s my side.”  As intriguing as that title is, the end tag line might be even better: “*flame suit on*”. As you’ve probably already guessed, this is a pretty interesting and controversial thread.

You’re going to have to bear with us because the story itself is pretty complex. So buckle up!The thread started with a sort of public release to explain an incident on Mt. Gox in which a man, Kevin, was able to get millions of dollars worth of Bitcoins for a fraction of the price.

Back on June 20th of 2011 someone for an unknown reason decided to sell off over 250,000 Bitcoins on Mt. Gox and didn’t set a minimum sell. It is believed that the Bitcoins being sold were stolen by a hacker who had amassed them and then sold them off en masse. Why and for what purpose still remains a mystery to this day.

When someone placed a sell order on Mt. Gox, the system would go through every buy order and satisfy it, starting with the highest bid and moving down until the minimum price is reached. In this case, the sell order was for the hundreds of thousands of Bitcoin and had no minimum price set.

Given the sell order’s massive size, it quickly met all the demand for higher end buy orders. Meaning everyone who wanted to buy the Bitcoins at or near the market rate had their orders fulfilled. A clever trader, “Kevin”, noticed that there was a huge amount of Bitcoin buy orders for 1 cent. So he basically bid 1.1 cents and offered to buy as many Bitcoins as possible.

When the sell order reached Kevin’s bid price, he was able to buy nearly 260,000 Bitcoins, all for less than $3,000 dollars. This was only a tiny fraction of the market price before the massive sell order was placed and Kevin secured millions of dollars worth of Bitcoin for only a few thousand dollars.

Kevin then withdrew about 650 bitcoins and left the rest in his Mt. Gox account. This immediately set off a firestorm. Some people thought Kevin was the hacker who stole the Bitcoins in the first place. Others thought he was simply in the right place at the right time. Most believed he was innocent, but also in possession of stolen goods and should return them.

In the end, Mt. Gox kept most of the Bitcoins and reversed the trades. The damage in was somewhat limited and the hack forced the Bitcoin community to focus more on security.  Read the original forum thread.

#2 – The first reported major theft of Bitcoins (1st most viewed)

Back in June of 2011 Bitcoin forum user Allinvain woke up to discover that someone had hacked 25,000 Bitcoins, then worth about $500,000 dollars, now worth about 16 million! The mind blowing part is that Allinvain noticed that his Slush Pool account had been hacked, and even then decided not to try to move or secure his Bitcoins.

Allinvain quickly reached out to the Bitcoin community, but found out what most of us already know: a Bitcoin stolen is a Bitcoin lost and there’s not much you can do to get it back. Allinvain admitted that it was his own carelessness that resulted in the tragic theft but losing a half million dollars is a tough way to learn a lesson.

This appears to be the first case of Bitcoins being stolen. Forum users began to brainstorm ways to protect Bitcoins, such as encryption methods, storing Bitcoins on dedicated operating systems (such as Linux on a flash drive),and other things. Many similar ideas would later be used to found many of the protection services offered to this day.

The heist, while terrible for Allinvain, did have some positive effects on Bitcoin. For one, people started to take security seriously. Yeah, it’s mind blowing that people would store thousands of dollars on unsecured computers but they did then, and many probably still do now. Two, it did garner the currency a lot of attention, and as they say, no publicity is bad publicity.

As many commenters on the forum noted, the story was bound to repeat itself over and over. And sadly it has. For whatever reason, people are slow learners and still continue to store vast amounts of Bitcoins in single wallets, often on computers connected to the Internet. Mt. Gox itself was also using lax security when it got hacked. Read the full thread.

#1 – The riddle that will get you 3.5BTC (1st most replied)

Amazingly enough the most replied to thread on BitcoinTalk was posted just 3 weeks ago (June 22nd 2014). The thread is an ARG puzzle which holds within it’s answer the private key to a 3.5BTC prize (at the time of posting worth around $2100).  In just 15 days this thread has amassed more than 2200 comments of people desperately trying to solve the puzzle.

The idea is that the puzzle start with a main image (posted below) and then hints are spread out different Internet mediums (Twitter hash tags, Reddit posts etc.). It took 2200 comments to solve the puzzle and the winner was a BitcoinTalk user named “GateKeeper“. The original poster (OP) posted this under a fake username and remain anonymous. Here’s a link to the complete solution of the puzzle (it’s 32 pages long).

Bitcoin ARG Puzzle

Read the original thread

Find the best exchange to buy Bitcoins


Ofir Beigel

Owner at 99 Coins ltd.
Blogger and owner of 99Bitcoins. I've been dealing with Bitcoin since the beginning of 2013 and it taught me a lesson in finance that I couldn't get anywhere else on the planet. I'm not a techie, I don't understand "Hashes" and "Protocols", I designed this website with people like myself in mind. My expertise is online marketing and I've dedicated a large portion of 99Bitcoins to Bitcoin marketing.

10 Comments

  1. Most major currencies are backed up by confidence in a national government or a gold/silver standard. What backs Bitcoin up? How do I know if I invest in Bitcoin that they will still be around in 10 years?

    • You don’t. Also the US dollar isn’t backed by gold, it’s just backed by “the faith and full credit of the US”. Bitcoin also isn’t backed up by anything and it’s value is given to it because of its trade volume and supply and demand of the market. You don’t know if it will be here in another 10 years and it’s still considered a risky investment. Digital currencies are definitely the future of money (in my opinion) and Bitcoin currently has the lead but things can always change.

    • Bitcoin is still risky so that’s why it is considered as an investment. When all the risks will be removed there will be no ROI to be made anymore, it will be just a very
      useful currency.

  2. That puzzle is way over my head. It’s a nice chunk of change though! I would totally suspect Kevin… Dude that was suspect! I mean… who buys millions of dollars worth of bitcoin and draws only a fraction of it? All’s well that ends well… I guess.

  3. I’d be worried if I was Hal about holding on to the Bitcoin. At over 600$ each why not cash it in now? I guess their only going to go up in value? It’s just such a young currency. What does the future of Bitcoin look like?

    • It’s true that if he has a good amount of Bitcoins to cash in now would be profitable, but he may be holding on to Bitcoin for other reasons. First, I believe the price will continue to rise so why cash out now ? Second, he may be holding it for ideological reasons….you can always ask him on the BitcoinTalk forum :)

  4. That’s a sad but inspirational story about Hal. Out of curiosity… how many Bitcoin did he mine before he gave up? That’s a nice inheritance. And smart to keep it off a vulnerable machine. Judging by all the Bitcoin thievery that’s been going on.

  5. So what limits the number of bitcoins that can be mined at 21 million? Does the value of each Bitcoin go down when new coins are mined?

    • The Bitcoin protocol states “the rules” of Bitcoin. Value is based on supply and demand so it’s logical that the value will go down when new Bitcoins are mined, but since the mining of Bitcoin progresses and a slow and constant rate (currently 25 new Bitcoins every 10 minutes) then it doesn’t effect it much.

Leave A Reply